Elly Clutch has just moved in next door to Ricky Johnson, and he's got a big crush on the redhead beauty. She's sweet, fun and flirty – the perfect girl-next-door! With sparks flying between them, it's not long before they start making out. Elly excuses herself to take a phone call. Ricky waits patiently for her to return, but the girl that comes back seems a little different… more dominant, dirty talking, and downright nasty! Ricky is confused but goes with the flow, enjoying this wilder version of Elly as she sits on his face. Once she comes, evil Elly exits and Good Elly returns. Neighbor guy is more confused than ever but quickly forgets his confusion as Good Elly gives him a blowjob. But it's not long before she has to leave again, allowing Evil Elly to swoop in and steal her twin's man once more. After sex the original Elly returns, shocked to find her evil twin has fucked her crush. The two Ellys argue back and forth while Ricky looks utterly confused. Which Elly do YOU like best?
